It鈥檚 a tough job and getting even tougher. CM explores the changing role of the site manager.

You鈥檝e got four concrete wagons in the queue and the slip form is going up when the foreman bursts in saying the winch motor on the crane just burned out. Your boss is in another part of the country soothing already tense relations with the client. Everybody is looking at you, waiting for instructions.

Oooh baby, baby, it鈥檚 a wild world... and getting wilder.

Some things don鈥檛 change. Site managers are still at the sharp end. Of all people, they are closest to that unholy trinity of Time, Cost and Quality. Emergencies that derail a package? Their problem. A dodgy patch of brickwork? Their problem. Little design oversights that cost thousands to fix? Their problem.

So what鈥檚 different? Plenty. Tougher clients, leaner management, stricter regulations and a more litigious public combine to make a hard job even harder. A Tesco store took 40 weeks to build 12 years ago and now the clients want it in 32. Contracts managers used to supervise a handful of projects, now they鈥檝e got a dozen, causing more authority to be delegated downward. Management wants up-to-the-minute profitability snapshots. Health and safety legislation requires reams of reportage. Site managers always had to cover their rear ends but now they need chain mail.

The old skills are still needed, but in much greater proportions.

Take technical ability, that is, knowing if the design is possible within time and budget and without hurting anybody. It may look good on paper, but you still need expert knowledge of materials and techniques. Site managers always had to spot things that won鈥檛 work, but now they鈥檙e under greater pressure to spot how things could work better.

鈥淚n the old days you got the plans, built it, and somebody paid for it,鈥 says Joe Darcy, senior contracts manager for Scanmoor Construction, himself a former site manager. 鈥淣ow you need to be adept at spec changes for financial gain.鈥

Site manager-turned-trainer Chris Westacott of Westacott Management Resources agrees.

In the old days, you built it and somebody paid for it. now you need to be adept at spec changes for financial gain

Joe Darcy, Scanmoor Construction

鈥淕ood site managers can see that if you moved those windows 35mm to the left you won鈥檛 have to split bricks,鈥 he says. 鈥淭hey see this but architects don鈥檛.鈥

And college alone can鈥檛 teach you this.

鈥淯nfortunately it means getting the hours in at the coal-face and there is still no sure-fire way this can be short-circuited,鈥 says Julian Daniel of Bovis Lend Lease, who won a gold medal for his work on the Treasury in last year鈥檚 Construction Manager of the Year Awards.

Brand spanking new capabilities are needed too. Take environmental management. This applies locally, at site level, because neighbours are likely to sue over noise, dust and traffic, but also globally because clients like to say their facilities are ecologically sound. Either way, the site manager should be able to devise waste reduction techniques.

The need for leadership 鈥 formerly known as politics 鈥 is also changing. In an age of partnering and integrated teams, the site manager can鈥檛 always resort to banging the table any more. They must develop their friendly muscles.

鈥淵ou鈥檝e got to embrace Egan, empathise, look at the situation through other people鈥檚 eyes,鈥 says Westacott. 鈥淣o more entrenching and digging your heels in. You鈥檝e got to find a win-win-win solution.鈥

But Westacott warns that too much democracy equals chaos. 鈥淲ithout good leadership skills the rank-and-file will suss you out in a morning,鈥 he says.

No more digging your heels in. you鈥檝e got to find a win-win-win solution

chris westacott

So how do you acquire these skills, or update the ones you鈥檝e already got?

Training is essential, and in this important way, things may be looking up for the site manager. Chris Westacott says more enlightened firms are supporting site managers by helping them get chartered through the direct membership examination route, known as DMX. Scanmoor Construction, a 拢40m turnover contractor near London, swears by this method. The company has put eight men through the one-day-a fortnight course already and another seven started last month. It costs around 拢1000 for each person, but it鈥檚 worth it, according to Darcy. For one thing it equips the men to handle the pressure. For another, it鈥檚 great at impressing the client.

鈥淲hen you fill in questionnaires for the client we find they鈥檙e looking for CVs for everyone,鈥 he said. 鈥淚t doesn鈥檛 look good to just say Joe Bloggs, no qualifications. They want to see they鈥檝e come up through a formal system.鈥

Most site managers rise through one of two routes: the hard-knocks path through trades like plumbing, brickwork or joinery; or propelled with an academic fuel injection of an engineering degree or higher national diploma (HND). Each type has its advantages. The tradesperson will know how the labour force ticks, how to motivate men on a Friday afternoon in February, and how to predict outputs accurately, while the more academically inclined might shine with written reports and communicating with the client.

鈥淭he academic is going to be good at the pre-delivery stage,鈥 confirms Darcy. 鈥淲inning the job, doing the risk analysis, grasping the conceptual design. But from there on, I would slightly favour someone from the skills background. Getting the job done.鈥

But more important than training, and deeper even than years of experience is the sort of person you are. The experienced managers we asked all pointed to a kind of moral rectitude that underlies knowledge, skill and experience.

2003鈥檚 Construction Manager of the Year, Malcolm Nelson of Laing O鈥橰ourke, calls it integrity: 鈥淚f you are straight in dealing with everyone you come across, without offending, and do what you say to the best of your ability, then ultimately most will respond. This is important to gain the respect of everyone in team and set the example for clear and unambiguous communication at all levels.鈥

You鈥檒l be a Man, my son!

CMYA gold medallist Julian Daniel on the site managers he admires

鈥淭hey live by strong moral codes and their commitment to deliver a job is unflinching, in the midst of great disappointment and struggle. They hear everyone鈥檚 reasons WHY NOT and then harness all energies towards the one reason WHY. When staff come to them and say that they have done their best and no one could do more, they pick up the pieces and produce a result beyond the comprehension of their people. They relish risk but manage it without fear.

They never cry wolf and have always been hard and fair, if sometimes not quite in the right proportions. They continuously improve and learn lessons well, not only from their own mistakes but those of other people. They plan to succeed and do so while most plan and expect to fail.

Because they are not afraid to make mistakes and can live with the consequences of their actions, they tend to be decisive while others prevaricate and wait for perfect conditions that may never materialise. They are 鈥榗an do鈥 mentality personified because most days that is exactly what they do do.鈥

Tricks of the trade

Only experience can teach the really important lessons. Here are four our experts suggested:

  • Ask the right questions, at the right time, to the right people and then hold them to account for their
    subsequent actions
  • Learn the subtle arts of diplomacy: 鈥淭he site manager I admired,鈥 says Malcolm Nelson, 鈥渨as a gentleman who had time for everyone and was overtly complimentary when someone had done a good job but could criticise and explain why a poor job was not acceptable without turning off the offendee.鈥
  • Dredge up some enthusiasm. If you鈥檙e not enthusiastic about what you need to achieve, how can you motivate people to share your vision when they probably don鈥檛 have the same stake in the overall process?
  • Avoid flim-flammery. A fag-packet sketch by a competent individual who understands the issues has far more value than slides produced by someone who copies a solution from their last job because they don鈥檛 know any better