Eight out of nine assemblies fear they will need more funds to fulfil regional housing role

The government鈥檚 flagging regional agenda was dealt a further blow this week when it emerged that eight of the nine unelected regional assemblies are worried they cannot afford to write regional housing strategies.

In a consultation that closed on Tuesday, the government outlined its hope that the unelected assemblies would take on responsibility for writing the strategies from regional housing boards next year.

The consultation also proposed merging regional housing and planning boards into the regional assemblies 鈥 this was recommended by Kate Barker in her March housing supply review.

When contacted by Housing Today, eight of the nine assemblies voiced concern about the level of extra resources they will receive from the ODPM to allow them to produce the strategies, which are key to housing provision across England.

The West Midlands assembly said that, in the worst-case scenario, it may have to 鈥渄ecline the opportunities offered by the merger [of regional housing and planning boards]鈥 if additional funding is not forthcoming.

The assemblies are worried because the government has said it does not 鈥渆nvisage providing any additional funding to support RHBs鈥 as the merger does not involve the creation of any new tasks or burdens.

Colin Robertshaw, head of policy at the East of England assembly, said: 鈥淚f we are going to fulfil this new role, including taking on the responsibilities of the regional housing board, it is inevitable we will have to take on new staff. It will be impossible to achieve without new resources.鈥

Estimates of merger costs vary from Yorkshire and Humber assembly鈥檚 鈥渃onservative鈥 拢150,000 to 拢170,000 a year, to East Midlands鈥 suggestion of an extra 拢250,000 being needed.

Andrew Pritchard, head of spatial planning at the East Midlands assembly, said: 鈥淲e agree there needs to be additional resources. The government can鈥檛 expect us to take on new duties without new resources. We hope the money would come from central government. It鈥檚 up to them to consider our proposed figure now.鈥

The ODPM鈥檚 response to the consultation is expected early next year. A spokesperson said it was too early to comment at this stage.

David Tretheway, director of strategy and local government at the South West assembly, said: 鈥淭here is an issue around resources. It鈥檚 a bit extreme to say we won鈥檛 go ahead if we don鈥檛 get additional resources, and we don鈥檛 take that position, but we recognise that we need to talk about it and resolve it.鈥

Sarah Webb, director of policy at the Chartered Institute of Housing, said the problem facing the assemblies was 鈥渆normous鈥. She said: 鈥淧roducing the regional housing strategy is very difficult and requires skilled people. We are seriously undermining the ability of the regional assemblies to deliver on this by not funding them properly."

North east

  • 72 members

  • Population: 2.5 million

"There is some concern about resources."

North west

  • l80 members

  • Population: 6.7 million

鈥淥ur initial expectation and costings require additional support from Government of around 拢200-250,000.鈥

West midlands

  • 100 members

  • Population: 5.3 million

鈥淲ithout these resources it will not be possible to deliver the new functions effectively.鈥

South west

  • 117 members

  • Population: 5 million

鈥淭he Assembly believes that the arrangements should be based on appropriate funding to support the work.鈥

Yorkshire & Humberside

  • 37 members

  • Population: 4.9 million

鈥淭he Assembly believes that there is a clear need for adequate, secure and consistent funding arrangements.鈥

East midlands

  • 111 members

  • Population: 4.2 million

"It is regrettable the consultation paper is unclear about the best means of ensuring this work is properly resourced."

East of England

  • 107 members

  • Population: 5.5 million

  • 鈥淲ithout some kind of transfer of resources this will be extremely difficult to achieve.鈥

    London

    • 25 members

    • Population: 7.3m

    鈥淭he mayor welcomes the consultation document 鈥 but believes he should also have the same powers as were proposed for the elected regional assembliesd鈥

    South east

  • 111 members

  • Population: 8m

  • 鈥淭he Assembly does not have the resources to fully support the Housing Board's future role.鈥